Hi All,
To be honest, I'm split in my thinking on this question.
In my heart-of-hearts, I think the Forum should focus only on BIR curries and cooking techniques. This is the origins of the Forum and it's purpose of being.
I agree with what Brum says, we can only really say that we have gone as far as we can once we can reliably and repeatably replicate decent BIR curries (w.r.t. their taste, smell and appearance) at home. And inform others how to do it. I don't subscribe to the view that we cannot do it (e.g. for reasons of scale, heat, etc).
It is a process (scale-up/down) issue and, as such, "simply" needs to be replicated on a smaller scale. It obviously requires some changes to the process to achieve the same result. Glibly said, I know, but it's what I believe....I am convinced that it can be done.
On the other hand, I also know that many people derive great value from the other recipe sections on the Forum. These other recipe sections seem to be quite popular with our members. There are some excellent recipes there too! If this is what most people want, perhaps we recognise and respond to that fact and enhance those sections (e.g. by adding other subsections as are now in BIR section)?
My personal concern is knowing where to draw the line? The Forum could easily become so diffuse as to be no different to the so many other Forums on the net.
I think, on balance, I'd prefer to see the Forum retain it's focus and uniqueness by focusing on BIR curries and cooking techniques.
What opinions and views do other people have?