I don't think anyone is in a really good position to say Paul.
I suspect no one has tried all of the recipes and we don't have a recipe rating system to indicate what members, who have tried the various recipes, feel about them.
I suggest you squiz through the various recipes and note the comments made by the various people in them.
Sorry I can't be of more help....but I think you're in danger of soliciting some pretty spurious responses (which, no doubt, you'll receive)!
