I see that a number of people have threatened to try this recipe (including CurryKing, MadrasAndy, George, JohnBoy, Fandango and Lagathy)
Hi
Good question. Why do we get feedback on relatively few recipes? Here's my excuse for not yet trying the CP base sauce.
1. I haven't made ANY base sauce since CP's base sauce recipe was posted, so it MAY still remain my number one priority the next time I make any curry or base sauce. My progress is slow. There are so many other things to do. I see BIR curries as quite unhealthy so I would never make one a week or anything like that.
2. When I next decide to make a base sauce, which one will I try? Possible contenders are the recent 2 onion German one which looks nice and simple, and this CP base sauce. But the CP base sauce looks anything but simple. It looks like it needs quite a lot of effort, which is a bit of a deterrent, if I'm honest.
3. Of greater concern than the effort required, is a worry that the effort may be wasted if the recipe is less than totally accurate. I had earlier concerns about inconsistencies in the huge capacities and quantities, which may well have been sorted out now. I'm not sure. It would take me 20 minutes (say) to crawl through this thread and double-check back to the original recipe - to see if it now appears to stack up and is worth a try. That's more effort....
4. CP suggested that a pro-rata reduction in quantities may not work or be anywhere near as good in taste terms. There's no way I'm going to purchase a 14 litre pan and hundreds of onions just to try this sauce and then give over perhaps a quarter of my freezer to storing the resultant base sauce. I'm sorry but it simply isn't practical. Either the sauce can be scaled back to work with 2 onions, or it's a non-starter for me.
5. My current, long-standing 'reference' base sauce is based on MarkJ's. I scaled that back to 2 onions and it tastes superb.
Regards
George