Quote from: Secret Santa on January 26, 2013, 10:11 AM
Quote from: BIR-TY on January 26, 2013, 09:13 AM
Didnt Julian C2GO claim his recipes deliver the secret to the takeaway taste? Well they didnt for me
I think it depends on when you started to eat curries as to whether you'll think the books deliver or not. If, like me and several others on the forum, you ate in the 70's and 80's they won't even come close to producing the taste and smell of that era. If you started in the 90's or later they may fit the bill.
The real test for me is always the bhuna. All of the 'secret' books give laughably poor bhunas in comparison to the rich, savoury unmistakably delicious flavour of old style bhunas. Now they think chucking a few pepper and onion chunks into the curry and cooking it to a thick consistency is a bhuna...well it ain't! 
If there is a 'secret', then I think it is simply technique and skill backed up by knowledge gained over many years of experience working in a professional kitchen environment, day in, day out. In other words, the chef is the 'secret'.
And this is admirably demonstrated by Secret Santa's bhuna example above.
In the 80s and into the early 90s the bhuna (specifically, lamb bhuna gosht, as it was described on the menu) was my curry of choice. Rich, intense, savoury and with a depth of flavour to die for, it was the benchmark I used to determine the quality of a chef in a restaurant, and when I found a good one I stuck to them like glue.
Sadly, the last decent bhuna I had was back in the early 90s, when the head chef of my favourite local restaurant went back to Bangladesh to visit an ailing relative, and never returned.
Since then, while the food at that establishment has remained above average, the classic bhuna is, sadly, no more. In it's place is the now industry standard curry which has merely been reduced over a high heat to produce a thick, cloying sauce.
Not one of the chefs taken on by that restaurant over the years can make the dish that the old chef made. For it wasn't a secret ingredient that made that bhuna what it was - it was the man who made it.
If I could find him and get him to teach me how he did it I would die a happy man...