If i was given that in a restaurant after ordering a Shami kebab, i would be pissed off and question the waiter. I would still eat it though because i'm sure it would still taste good. And maybe thats what the chef believes to be a Shami kebab.
But its nothing like any Shami ive ever had and i've been eating them since i was about 5 or 6 years old!
Just because its flat and round?? And red? :

A proper shami should have a very fine pasted meat not just minced.
Its about texture.