Fancied a 'trad' Indian the other day: did her version of Rogan Josh, I was just as dissapointed with the result as I was when I did Camellia Punjabi's (from 50 best Curries Of India) version of Rogan Josh too!
Maybe I'm doing it wrong, but I saw it demonstrated on the TV during her present series, and I was careful to follow the techniques she advised. I felt the spice balance was wrong, way to much cardomom flavour. Although I was impreseed by the smell of the fennel seed based masala. I think I may give BIR-style recipies containing kashmiri masala a go as a result...
I must say her recipe for Vindalo looks attractive, but after my Rogan Josh experience I'm not sure I'll bother.....