Harsh chewy
The recipe was halved , the first stage was boiled for 2 hours , the spices added and simmered half hour , the garlic tarka added and cooked for hour as half hour didn't taste cooked enough, as Jb said half hour if not longer, where's the problem?
I asked about chef spoon measurements as there is a lot of debate on the matter, haldi says 4 desert spoons you say 2 Tbs Jb says it looked like 4Tbs , lot of variation there.
As for pictures I haven't had chance to upload them as I have not been at home to access my laptop for most of the day.
Half a clove of garlic?
As for messing about with people's recipes , I always cook people's recipes to spec first , if I don't like them I don't cook them again, if there are parts of the recipe I like I use it, don't see what the problem is

Cheers MA