I agree completely and have said so before. I also believe some of the recipes here are ta clones and perfectly sound ie, taz's, Dips, also a new convert to the abc book. Im sorry i still have not tried some of CA's recipes and other very well received recipe's from the site but do not doubt that they are good also.
I don't believe any more that there is a holy grail or missing ingredient. I think in some cases technique is important, but only in so far as frying spices and or gg paste.
My friends and family have all said the same as your friends and family, our currries are as good as or better than...blah blah. I have bought a meal and thought that it wasn't as good as my home made efforts.
And i concede that some restaurants are just as you say, better than our home made efforts.
Confidence is a major factor for me. The way i quite literally throw a curry together now when compared to my early efforts is something else.
The problem is it makes me/us sound arrogant to say these things.
The next step for me, is to use the recipes i am familiar with and make them more subtle, i actually want to move a little towards the top restaurants flavours and more away from the local ta flavour, if you know what i mean.
Yes i agree 101%.