Quote from: getonthegarabi on September 08, 2012, 07:57 PMAny suggestions for a proper bir madras Santa? I'm thinking about trying 976s recipe. Rob. 
Honestly, no.
A proper BIR madras is the kind (in my opinion) that was available everywhere in the early eighties and that appears to be available no more. None of the recipes on this site match it and my own version, which is little different to those, doesn't matches it either.
In general though I think a madras should be very simple. It has to be more tomatoey than a vindaloo (that'll conflict straight away with other opinions) so it needs some tomato puree. Then it's just some mix powder, a decent amount of chilli, a bit of methi, all purpose seasoning, g/g paste, base sauce and spiced oil and a few wedges of tomato at the end. Definitely no souring agent such as lemon, lemon dressing or worcester sauce. All of those take a madras a million miles from those I knew in the eighties and again, in my opinion, make it (a lot) worse for it. And, as with any basic, savoury curry, no sugar should be added as any sweetness should come from the base sauce. Chicken stock is optional but definitely adds to the savoury flavour.
Oh, and the GM added at the end is an absolute no-no. That's an authentically Indian way to spice a curry but it gives it a very 'flowery' overtone that is just not natural in old style BIR curries. If you use GM then don't overdo it and make it part of the mix powder so that it gets added at the start and has time to mellow.