I have tried this method of making a tube and coiling it again and again..and i havent had good results...the dough has to be very soft and pliable and the technique is hard.
My method is using atta, water and bit of salt. Thre is no need for oil/ghee but i usually add a few drops while kneading the dough. basically, when you have the dough, make largish balls - golf ball sized maybe. roll out into a 4-5 inch circle with the help of flour to dust it with. Then smear a little bit of ghee all over the circle. Make a cut from the center to the edge of the circle. Pick up the cut edge and roll it all the way around so you have a cone that stands up at the end. It is hard to describe really! It doesnt roll perfectly so thats ok, preferred maybe!! Then with the cone standing up, push it down with the palm of your hand into a small circle. You will see a spiral in the dough. Then dust with flour and roll out as thin as possible. Almost as thin as for rotis!! Place of tawa, flip after few seconds and apply little ghee on it, flip and apply ghee to original side. Press down with spatula to cook. you should see it puff up and the layers separate out due to the ghee being applied "between" the layers.
The recipe from Baljekar's cookbok uses a ton if butter!!! If anyone gives my method a try, let me know if it works for you. These are very light as opposed to the thickish, heavy paranthas but taste very different from rotis!
Payal